Coasting: The mystery of the Amelia Island Light

Amelia Island at Fernandina Beach

Amelia Island at Fernandina Beach

The last stop on our Coasting adventure was brief.  Too brief.  And, as it turned out, a bit of a mystery.  We arrived in Amelia Island, Florida, early on a Friday afternoon, anxious to see as much as we could before heading home the next morning.

At a public access, we walked from the parking lot out to the beach.  The view?  Large, naturally rough sand dunes and a wide stretch of beach that looked even wider on a rather foggy afternoon.  (Would love to know what the beach is like on a “crowded” day.)

Then off to find the third lighthouse on our tour, the Amelia Island Lighthouse. (Read about the lighthouses on Tybee Island and St. Augustine in our earlier posts.)  And that’s where the mystery began.

We set the GPS for Lighthouse Road but with no luck.  (We know now from this site to look for North Wolff Street.)  Since we could see the lighthouse in the distance, we kept driving around until Lighthouse Road finally opened up in a subdivision.  Between two houses.  That’s right.  No visitor lot.  No signage.  We wondered what was going on.

Traveling between the two houses on a short stretch took us to a locked gate.  And that’s where the journey ended.  We stared at this sign and went no further.

Sign at Amelia Island Lighthouse

Sign at Amelia Island Lighthouse

With no more information than what we are sharing here, we snapped a picture through the chain-link fence of the lighthouse, even with that pole of a tree obstructing our view. But try as we did, we couldn’t get a better shot since we couldn’t get past the gate.

Our best shot, pole and all, of the Amelia Island Light taken through a chain-link fence

Our best shot, pole and all, of the Amelia Island Light taken through a chain-link fence

One thing for sure:  The Amelia Island Light is lovely.  Standing tall in its white “clothing” only, the lighthouse looked old (and it is) and intriguing (and it is).

So here’s the limited information we found through an Internet search back home.  No guarantees this is accurate.  It’s the mystery we haven’t solved.  But it’s better than nothing.

Just the facts we could find:

  • It’s the oldest lighthouse in Florida located on Amelia Island in Fernandina Beach.
  • Built in 1838-1839, it’s perched high on a bluff above Egan’s Creek.
  • It’s only one of two remaining lighthouses in the state designed by Winslow Lewis, an American lighthouse builder.
  • It’s a double-walled lighthouse — a “cone within a cone” — that stands 67 feet tall and houses a very rare granite staircase.

If you want to see Amelia Island Light . . . 

  • You must make a reservation in advance with Fernandina Beach Recreation Center located on Atlantic Avenue in Fernandina, by calling (904)310-3350.
  • Tours are available only on the first and third Wednesdays, leaving the Rec Center promptly at 10:00.  Tickets are $5.00 for adults, $3.00 for children under 12.
  • Lighthouse tours don’t allow visitors to climb the stairs.
  • Property tours are open to the public on Saturdays from 11:00 AM to 2:00 PM.

And that’s all we know about Amelia Island Lighthouse, a light that beckons from the locked gate — and probably looks better up close!

If you’ve been, leave us a comment about what you saw.  This is one mystery we’d love to solve, but we’ll have to get to Amelia Island on a Wednesday!


Amelia Island Lighthouse Tour, City of Fernandina Beach

Amelia Island Lighthouse Tours Fernandina Beach, September 16, 2010

“Amelia Island, FL.”


For more posts in our Coasting series, click here.

9 thoughts on “Coasting: The mystery of the Amelia Island Light

    1. Oh, the Places We See

      You know, we should have a better idea of when things are open and when they’re not. It never even occurred to me to look this up prior to the trip out there. All the other lighthouses were open 7 days a week, so I thought this one would be also. Live and learn. And check the schedules!!! After all, we have Internet now!!!

    1. Oh, the Places We See

      Really loved this lighthouse and am now intrigued by it. May someday be able to see it. There are also lovely places to rent on the beach, and that, too, looked right up my alley! Thanks for taking a look.

  1. Judy @ newenglandgardenandthread

    I love lighthouses – all of them. They are so stately and each one is unique. We have one here on the coast that is on a functioning Coast Guard Station. If the terror level is raised, you cannot access the lighthouse. Near or far, this is a beautiful lighthouse.

    1. Oh, the Places We See

      Thanks so much for commenting. We love lighthouses, too, but haven’t been to many. We’ve met people who have committed to seeing all the lighthouses along the Eastern Coast, for example. Sounds fun, really. I’ve also heard that there are lighthouses you can stay in. That, too, would be fun. Best wishes for a good week ahead.

      1. yprior1

        🙂 – well really sometimes these make the best shots – and are more in sync with what we really see vs. a brochure feel… have a nice weekend

It makes our day to hear from you.